Checking the App Against the Rulebook
Why Care?
An app that runs your league’s money has to get the money exactly right, every time. A cap number that’s off by a few dollars isn’t a rounding error. It’s an argument in the group chat and a commissioner doing math by hand.
So we put FantasyGM’s logic side by side with how the league really plays, and went through it one line at a time.
What’s New?
- A line-by-line audit. We compared what the app calculates with what the league’s own records say, across every part of the front office: budgets, contracts, keepers, rosters, standings, and prizes.
- Thirteen decisions, all made. Each mismatch got a clear answer from the commissioner’s chair. Some turned out to be the app’s mistake, some were ours, and a couple were both right in different ways.
- More power to commissioners. A recurring answer was “the commissioner decides.” Many of the rules we’d assumed were fixed are really league choices, so FantasyGM will let each league set them its own way.
- A plan for the next phase, split into focused pieces instead of one giant rewrite.
The Story
The most satisfying finding was a mystery that solved itself. Two teams’ numbers didn’t match between the app and the league’s records, and it looked like a bug. It wasn’t. It was a trade, with a little cash thrown in, recorded two different ways. Both were right. That one example taught us more about how the app should store money than any amount of planning would have.
We also caught one of our own misreadings: a shorthand in the league’s records meant something different from what we first assumed. Going one row at a time, and asking instead of guessing, is what surfaced it.
What’s Next
Turning the decisions into specs, one piece at a time. As before, we’ll keep the details close until they ship.
Written with Claude Code on Claude Opus 5.5.